Genetic diversity of Clostridium perfringens type A isolates from animals, food poisoning outbreaks and sludge
http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/articlerender.fcgi?artid=1513381
Comment
The authors expect you to know that Clostridium perfringens cause necrosis, bacteremia, emphysematous cholecystitis,
and gas gangrene. It is commonly referred to as the flesh eating bacteria or associated with necrotizing fasciitis --a rare
disease in 1990.
BMC Microbiol. 2006; 6: 47.
Published online 2006 May 31. doi: 10.1186/1471-2180-6-47.
Copyright © 2006 Johansson et al; licensee BioMed Central Ltd.
Genetic diversity of Clostridium perfringens type A isolates from animals, food poisoning outbreaks and sludge
Anders Johansson,1,2 Anna Aspan,1 Elisabeth Bagge,1 Viveca Båverud,1 Björn E Engström,1 and Karl-Erik Johansson1,2
1National Veterinary Institute, SE-751 89 Uppsala, Sweden
2Division of Bacteriology and Food Hygiene, Department of Biomedical Sciences and Veterinary Public Health, Swedish University of
Agricultural Sciences, Uppsala, Sweden
Corresponding author.
Anders Johansson: [email protected]; Anna Aspan: [email protected]; Elisabeth Bagge: [email protected]; Viveca
Båverud: [email protected]; Björn E Engström: [email protected]; Karl-Erik Johansson: [email protected]
Received February 17, 2006; Accepted May 31, 2006.
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.
org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is
properly cited.
Abstract
Background
Clostridium perfringens, a serious pathogen, causes enteric diseases in domestic animals and food poisoning in humans. The
epidemiological relationship between C. perfringens isolates from the same source has previously been investigated chiefly by pulsed-
field gel electrophoresis (PFGE). In this study the genetic diversity of C. perfringens isolated from various animals, from food
poisoning outbreaks and from sludge was investigated.
Results
We used PFGE to examine the genetic diversity of 95 C. perfringens type A isolates from eight different sources. The isolates were
also examined for the presence of the beta2 toxin gene (cpb2) and the enterotoxin gene (cpe). The cpb2 gene from the 28 cpb2-
positive isolates was also partially sequenced (519 bp, corresponding to positions 188 to 706 in the consensus cpb2 sequence). The
results of PFGE revealed a wide genetic diversity among the C. perfringens type A isolates. The genetic relatedness of the isolates
ranged from 58 to 100% and 56 distinct PFGE types were identified. Almost all clusters with similar patterns comprised isolates with
a known epidemiological correlation.
Most of the isolates from pig, horse and sheep carried the cpb2 gene. All isolates originating from food poisoning outbreaks carried
the cpe gene and three of these also carried cpb2. Two evolutionary different populations were identified by sequence analysis of the
partially sequenced cpb2 genes from our study and cpb2 sequences previously deposited in GenBank.
Conclusion
As revealed by PFGE, there was a wide genetic diversity among C. perfringens isolates from different sources. Epidemiologically
related isolates showed a high genetic similarity, as expected, while isolates with no obvious epidemiological relationship expressed a
lesser degree of genetic similarity. The wide diversity revealed by PFGE was not reflected in the 16S rRNA sequences, which had a
considerable degree of sequence similarity. Sequence comparison of the partially sequenced cpb2 gene revealed two genetically
different populations. This is to our knowledge the first study in which the genetic diversity of C. perfringens isolates both from
different animals species, from food poisoning outbreaks and from sludge has been investigated.
Background
Clostridium perfringens, an anaerobic Gram-positive bacterium known to be a common pathogen in humans, in domestic animals and
in wildlife, is the primary cause of clostridial enteric disease in domestic animals. The complete genome sequence of C. perfringens
has been published previously [1]. C. perfringens has 10 rRNA operons whose heterogeneity was investigated by Shimizu et al. [2].
They found 18 polymorphic sites among the 16S rRNA genes. A common feature of C. perfringens is the large number of exotoxins
produced; 17 different exotoxins have been described in the literature [3]. In addition, C. perfringens produces an enterotoxin, CPE
[4].
Clostridium perfringens is subdivided into five toxinotypes (A - E) based on the production of the four major exotoxins (viz. alpha,
beta, epsilon, and iota). The major toxins together with the enterotoxin and the beta2 toxin [5], play an important role in several
serious diseases [3,6]. CPE causes food-borne disease in humans, canine enteritis and porcine enteritis. Beta2 toxin, recently
described [5], has been associated with enteric diseases in domestic animals, especially piglets [7-9] and horses [10]. However, two
recently published studies, by Jost et al. [11] and Vilei et al. [12], demonstrated that beta2 toxin, encoded by cpb2, was expressed by
most porcine C. perfringens isolates, but seldom by isolates of non-porcine origin. The results of those studies indicate that beta2
toxin does not cause enteritis in animal species other than pigs. Vilei et al. [12] reported that gentamicin and streptomycin induced
expression of an atypical cpb2 gene in a non-porcine isolate. In a recent publication by Waters et al. [13], it was reported that cpb2
of C. perfringens from horses was transcriptionally active and that the levels of cpb2 mRNA were 35-fold lower than a high beta2
toxin producing pig isolate. Isolates originating from humans with gastrointestinal diseases carrying both cpb2 and cpe have recently
been described [14,15].
The epidemiological relationship between C. perfringens isolates has previously been investigated primarily by pulsed-field gel
electrophoresis (PFGE) and in most of these studies a majority of isolates from food poisoning outbreaks were examined [16-21]. C.
perfringens isolates originating from poultry have also been investigated previously by PFGE [22-24]. The general conclusions drawn
from the previously published articles, concerning both food poisoning outbreaks and animals, is that isolates from the same outbreak
have very similar patterns while the genetic diversity is high in non-outbreak isolates and isolates selected randomly [17-19,21-24].
The problem of DNA degradation of certain isolates due to endogenous bacterial nucleases, which are rather common among
clostridial isolates, has been discussed elsewhere [16,18,25,26].
The purpose of this study was to compare the genetic relationships of C. perfringens type A from eight different sources by PFGE.
A further aim was to investigate the distribution of the cpb2 and cpe genes. The cpb2 gene from all cpb2-positive isolates was also
partially sequenced. In this study a generally wide genetic diversity of C. perfringens isolates from eight different sources was found.
Furthermore, PFGE clearly distinguished between unrelated isolates of C.perfringens and supported a clonal relationship between
related isolates. Sequence analysis of the partially sequenced cpb2 gene revealed two genetically different populations of the gene.
Results
PCR
Multiplex PCR detected only the alpha-toxin gene (plc) and all isolates were therefore classified as C. perfringens type A. Altogether
28 isolates carried the cpb2 gene and 17 carried the cpe gene (Table 1). The cpb2 gene was found in 6 of the 8 groups studied: pigs
(83%), horses (60%), sheep (50%), food poisoning outbreaks (20%), sludge (21%) and poultry (10%). The cpb2 gene was not
detected in any of the isolates from roedeer or wild birds. The cpe gene was found in all isolates originating from food poisoning
outbreaks and in one isolate each from horse and roedeer. Both cpb2 and cpe were found in three isolates originating from outbreaks
of food poisoning.
PFGE
Of the 101 isolates of C. perfringens examined in this study, 88 were successfully characterized by PFGE after genomic DNA
digestion with SmaI (Table 1, Figure 1). The SmaI PFGE patterns of some of these isolates are shown in Figure 2. The genetic
relatedness of the isolates ranged from 57 to 100% and 56 distinct PFGE profiles were observed. Cluster analysis of PFGE data
showed no apparent relationship between the source of the isolate and its PFGE profile. However, the isolates originating from food
poisoning outbreak formed distinct clusters in the dendrogram (Figure 1). Altogether, 17 PFGE profiles with indistinguishable
patterns were found. Most of the isolates having PFGE profiles with indistinguishable patterns were from the same outbreak of
disease. All of the eight food isolates clustering with indistinguishable patterns originated from the same outbreak of food poisoning.
The poultry and porcine isolates clustering with indistinguishable patterns were also isolated from the same outbreaks. Two of the
PFGE profiles with indistinguishable patterns contained isolates with no obvious epidemiological correlation. Of the 28 cpb2-positive
isolates, 22 were successfully characterized by PFGE. The SmaI PFGE patterns of these isolates are shown in Figure 3. The overall
genetic relatedness of the cpb2-positive isolates was 63%. All the 10 isolates originating from pigs cluster together with a genetic
relatedness of 72%. This cluster was subdivided into four subclusters with 100% genetic relatedness in each cluster.
Sequence data analysis
In the phylogenetic tree (Figure 4) two main groups of the partially sequenced cpb2 gene (the distance matrix comprised 425
nucleotide positions, corresponding to positions 282 to 706 in the consensus cpb2 sequence) were observed, I and II, each
subdivided to three subclusters, a, b, c. A total of six groups could be identified (Figure 4, Table 2). Groups I and II are mutually
related, with a sequence similarity of 73.8%. All isolates in our study were found in group I. The sequence similarities within this
group varied between 93.3% and 100%. Our cpb2 sequences from porcine (Ia) and from non-porcine (Ib) cluster with the cpb2
sequences deposited by Vilei et al [12]. The three cpb2 sequences from food and the horse isolate AN 5036/01 was found in group
Ic. Most of the isolates in group II were isolated in the USA, while most of those in group I were isolated in Europe.
Sequencing of the 16S rRNA gene revealed a very high similarity among the 11 isolates analysed. As shown in Table 3, altogether 18
polymorphic sites were detected in the 16S rRNA region between nucleotide no. 91 and 1401 (based on the consensus sequence of
the 16S rRNA gene in the 10 rRNA operons of C. perfringens strain 13, rrnA - rrnI). Seven of the polymorphisms found in our
isolates were also found in C. perfringens strain 13 [2]. At position 154 of the 16S rRNA genes, one nucleotide difference was
observed; at this position, isolates from food poisoning outbreaks (AN 4279/01 455/99) had a T, whereas all others had a C. This
was the only nucleotide difference involving all operons that was observed in the sequenced isolates.
Discussion
Prevalence of the cpb2 and cpe genes
The high prevalence of the cpb2 gene in isolates from pigs and horses is consistent with other studies reporting a high prevalence of
cpb2 in pigs and horses suffering from gastrointestinal diseases [7-10]. The distribution of cpe in isolates of animal origin is low,
which also tallies with data from other studies [27-29]. Isolates from food poisoning outbreaks typically carry a chromosomal cpe
gene [21,30,31]; in this study three of these isolates also carried the cpb2 gene. In this study three of the isolates from food
poisoning outbreaks also carried the cpb2 gene. Isolates originating from humans with gastrointestinal diseases, carrying both cpb2
and cpe, have been described recently [14,15].
PFGE analysis
The aim of this study was to elucidate the general genetic diversity of C. perfringens type A isolated from a variety of sources in
Sweden and Norway. In the present study, any band difference between two PFGE types was considered sufficient to distinguish
between two different PFGE types. The results obtained by PFGE reveal a wide genetic diversity and no definite relationship between
the source of the isolate and the positions in the dendrogram can be established.
The wide genetic diversity revealed in this study was not unexpected, because of the wide diversity of the isolates analysed. Previous
studies on C. perfringens by PFGE have shown that isolates from the same food poisoning outbreak have a very similar pattern [18-
20] and that C. perfringens isolated from retail food showed a high genetic variation [17]. This has also been observed in poultry
where isolates from diseased birds showed a similar pattern, whereas the genetic diversity was considerable in isolates from healthy
birds [22-24]. Those observations are consistent with our results, where we can see that PFGE profiles with indistinguishable
patterns in almost all cases contain isolates having a known epidemiological connection. Comparison of the PFGE patterns of the
cpb2-positive isolates revealed a clonal relationship among the porcine isolates (group Ia), which cluster together in the dendrogram
(Figure 3). However, no clonal relationship could be established for isolates belonging to groups Ib and Ic. The cpb2 gene is known
to be located on several low copy number plasmids [5,15]. The genetic diversity of cpb2-positive isolates is therefore, not surprising,
as PFGE mainly reflects the chromosomal diversity.
In this study 13% of the isolates were non-typable due to DNA degradation. This problem has been reported previously [16,18,32]. It
is a disadvantage when PFGE is used as a subtyping method for clostridial species. However, problems with DNA degradation have
not been reported previously when analysing poultry isolates by PFGE [22-24]. As in this study none of the isolates from poultry,
horses or pigs were found degraded, PFGE is a very suitable method for epidemiological investigation of enteric diseases caused by
C. perfringens. The 16S rRNA gene was sequenced for three of the isolates that were found degraded. Neither DNA degradation nor
the generally wide genetic diversity was reflected in the 16S rRNA sequences, which were very similar. The use of Salmonella
enterica subsp. enterica serotype Braenderup, (Salmonella Braenderup H9812), digested with XbaI as a size marker made it easier to
normalize tiff images, than by using a commercially available weight marker, thanks to stable levels of DNA in the prepared plugs
[33].
In our opinion, PFGE is a reliable and robust method that can be used in combination with epidemiological data to establish C.
perfringens as the etiological agent whether in food-borne outbreaks or in outbreaks of enteric disease in domestic animals.
Sequence analysis of the cpb2 gene
Sequence analysis of the cpb2 gene (Figure 4) indicated the existence of two evolutionary differing populations based on 425
nucleotide positions, corresponding to positions 282 to 706 in the consensus cpb2 sequence. A relatively high sequence difference of
26.2% showed that cpb2 evolved into two different variants (I and II). The isolates sequenced in this study all belonged to group I
and were divided into three sub-clusters: porcine isolates (Ia), animal isolates of non-porcine origin (Ib), and isolates from food
poisoning outbreaks (Ic). One of the horse isolates AN 5036/01 clustered together with the food isolates. Most of the group I cpb2-
positive isolates were of European origin [12], while most cpb2-positive isolates from group II had an American origin [11].
However, isolates containing cpb2 isolated from humans with a gastrointestinal disease were distributed in both groups (Ic and IIa),
irrespective of origin [15]. Groups I and II both contained isolates capable of expressing CPB2 and also isolates that express non-
detectable levels of beta2 toxin [11,12,15]. Jost et al. [11] identified a cpb2 gene that was present in most non-porcine isolates. The
cpb2 sequences deposited by Jost et al. [11] were all affiliated to group II (IIa, IIb or IIc). Isolates from European animals carrying
the cpb2 gene were all affiliated to group I. It is interesting that none of the cpb2-positive isolates from animals in Europe carried the
cpb2 gene, which are found in group II.
Sequence analysis of the 16S rRNA gene
The reason for sequencing the 16S rRNA gene was to ascertain whether the diversity found by PFGE analysis was reflected in the
16S rRNA gene. Isolates that were degraded and those found in different clusters in the PFGE dendrogram showed a very high
sequence similarity. However, we found 18 positions with polymorphisms among our investigated isolates (Table 3). These
polymorphisms are caused by the fact that C. perfringens carries 10 rRNA operons and sequence differences exist between them.
Some of these polymorphisms were isolate specific. Seven of those found by us were also found by Shimizu et al. [2] who analysed
all the 10 rRNA operons of C. perfringens strain 13. The polymorphisms found in the C. perfringens 16S rRNA genes reflect certain
diversity. In a few other bacterial species polymorphisms have been used for subtyping [34], but due to the 10 rRNA operons in C.
perfringens, it is more difficult to use the polymorphism pattern for subtyping.
Conclusion
In this study a wide genetic diversity of C. perfringens was found when isolates from eight different sources were analysed by
PFGE. Degradation of DNA was observed in 13% of the isolates investigated. The considerable diversity found by PFGE was not
reflected in the 16S rRNA sequences, which were very similar. As expected, C. perfringens isolates from the same outbreak seemed
to be similar genetically, while isolates with no obvious epidemiological connection differed more noticeably. The groups with the
highest genetic relatedness were isolates from food-borne outbreaks and pig isolates carrying the cpb2 gene. Isolates from the other
sources were more widely dispersed in the dendrogram. Two genetically differing populations of the partially sequenced cpb2 gene
were found by sequence analysis. Furthermore, isolates causing enteric diseases in humans and other animals seem not to have a
strong genetic relatedness, based on PFGE analysis. We conclude that PFGE is a reliable and robust method for genotyping of C.
perfringens isolates.
Methods
Bacterial isolates and growth conditions
Altogether 95 isolates of C. perfringens type A were obtained from eight different sources: poultry (n = 20), pigs (n = 12), horses (n
= 10), sheep (n = 6), roedeer (n = 12), wild birds (n = 6), food poisoning outbreaks (n = 15) and environmental samples (n = 14)
(Table 1). The isolates were collected between 1994 to 2003 (Table 1), all isolates from sludge were collected 2002. One C.
perfringens type strain CCUG 1795 (A) and five reference strains, CIP 106526 (A), CCUG 2035 (B), CCUG 2036 (C), CCUG 2037
(D) and CCUG 44727 (E), were also included in the study. CCUG strains were obtained from the Culture Collection of the University
of Gothenburg, Sweden; the CIP strain was obtained from the Culture Collection of Institute Pasteur, Paris, France. The C.
perfringens isolates were identified as type A by applying standard biochemical tests and multiplex-PCR [22]. The isolates were
stored at -70°C. Thawed isolates were grown on fastidious anaerobe agar (FAA) (LabM, Bury, Lancashire, England) with 10%
defibrinated horse blood and incubated in anaerobic jars at 37°C.
PCR
The four major toxin genes plc, cpb1, iap and etx were detected by a modified version of the multiplex PCR assay of Engström et al.
[22]. Template DNA (2 μl), prepared by the direct lysis method of Herholz et al. [10] was added to a 50 μl reaction mixture, with the
following reagents: 50 mM KCl, 10 mM Tris-HCl (pH 8.3), 2.5 mM MgCl2, 50 nM of each deoxynucleotide, 1 U of AmpliTaq Gold
DNA polymerase (Applied Biosystems, Foster City, USA), 50 nM of each plc (α-toxin) primer, 25 nM of each cpb1 primer, 100 nM
of each etx primer and 25 nM of each iap primer. The thermocycling (incubations for 1 min at 94°C, 55°C and 72°C, respectively,
repeated 35 times) was preceded by incubation for 10 min at 94°C. The presence of the CPB2 gene (cpb2) and enterotoxin gene
(cpe) was also determined. cpb2 primers (250 nM) from Herholz et al. [10] and cpe primers (50 nM) from Kadra et al. [35] were
used in a duplex PCR. The conditions were as in the multiplex PCR, except for the annealing temperature, which was 59°C. The
amplicons were analysed by electrophoresis on a 1.5% agarose gel according to standard procedures.
PFGE
The isolates analysed by PFGE are listed in Table 1. The PFGE protocol of Lukinmaa et al. [20] was followed in all essentials. DNA
was digested with SmaI. Electrophoresis was performed at 6 V/cm with 2.0% AgaroseNA agar (Amersham Biosciences, Uppsala,
Sweden) by using the CHEF-DR II system (Bio-Rad Laboratories, Richmond, Calif, USA). Running conditions for SmaI-digested
DNA were 0.5 to 40 s for 20 h. Lambda ladder with a size range of 0.13 to 194 kb (Low Range PFG Marker, New England Biolabs
Inc.) and Salmonella Braenderup (H9812) digested with XbaI, which is described in greater detail by Hunter et al. [33], were used as
molecular weight standards. The DNA bands were visualized on a UV transilluminator and Polaroid photographs of the gels were
scanned and images in tiff file format were imported into GelCompar II (Applied Maths, Kortrijk, Belgium). Degrees of similarity
between isolates were calculated with 1.4% tolerance and 0.5% optimization by applying the band-based Dice similarity coefficient.
Clustering analysis was performed with the unweighted pair group method (UPGMA), by average linkages.
Sequence analysis of the 16S rRNA genes
The 16S rRNA genes of the isolates were amplified with primers [36] suitable for members of the phylum Firmicutes (Table 4). The
amplicons were used for cycle sequencing with labelled terminators (Big Dye; Applied Biosystems, Foster City, Calif, USA) and with
the sequencing primers listed in Table 4. The sequencing products were analysed with an ABI Prism 3100 genetic analyser (Applied
Biosystems) and contigs were generated with the Contig Express program included in the Vector NTI Suite (InforMax, Bethesda,
Md, USA). The contigs were edited manually with the Genetic Data Environment software [37] before further analysis and
deposition in GenBank.
Sequence analysis of the cpb2 genes
The cpb2 gene of the 28 cpb2-positive isolates was amplified with the β2 primers (250 nM) from Herholz etal. [10] and these
primers were also used in the cycle sequencing reaction, as described earlier. The cpb2 sequences determined in this work were
aligned with sequences retrieved from GenBank by the AlignX program in the Vector NTI Suite. The alignment was checked with
the Genetic Data Environment software [37]. A phylogenetic tree comprising 88 cpb2 sequences was constructed by the neighbour-
joining method [38] from a distance matrix that was corrected for multiple substitutions at single locations by the two-parameter
method [39]. A representative of cluster Ib was chosen as outgroup. Only one representative for each subgroup was included in the
final tree. The distance matrix comprised 425 nucleotide positions, corresponding to positions 282 to 706 in the cpb2 sequence of C.
perfringens, isolate P762/97 [Gen Bank:AJ537531]. Consenus alignments are shown in Additional file 1.
Nucleotide sequence accession numbers
The sequences of the cpb2 gene of the 28 cpb2-positive isolates have been deposited in GenBank (National Center for Biotechnology,
Bethesda, Md, USA) under accession numbers [GenBank:DQ201544 - GenBank:DQ201571]. The 16S rRNA sequences have also
been deposited in GenBank under accession numbers [GenBank:DQ196132 - GenBank:DQ196142].
Acknowledgements
This study was financially supported by grants from the Swedish Farmers' Foundation for Agricultural Research and the Swedish
National Veterinary Institute. We also wish to acknowledge the support of the European Concerted Action QLK2-CT2001-01267 on
genus Clostridium. The authors are grateful to Marianne Persson for excellent technical assistance. We thank Per Einar Granum,
Norwegian School of Veterinary Science, Oslo, Norway, for kindly providing isolates from food poisoning outbreaks. Further we
thank the Department of Wildlife, National Veterinary Institute, Uppsala, Sweden for kindly providing data about the isolates from
wild animals.